In a letter dated Nov. 20, 2015, a particular insurance company reminded me that I need to think about healthcare costs. I got a breakdown of how often in the quarter I used proprietary vs. generic drugs, how I compared to other rheumatologists, and how I compared to other physicians. I also got a list of the drugs that I used and alternatives that I should be thinking about instead. In principle, this is not a terrible idea. But let me describe some glaring mistakes that show that these letters are in fact a contradiction in themselves. They are a huge waste of resources.
The letter suggested that my number one “prescribed brand drug with potential member savings opportunities” was Uloric, costing an average of $302 per prescription. The suggested “generic” alternative was Colcrys, leading to a “potential annual cost savings” of $600.
Third drug on my list? Colcrys, coming in at $165 per prescription with a potential annual savings of $300. Listed alternative: allopurinol.
We rheumatologists know that Colcrys is not an alternative to Uloric, and allopurinol is not an alternative to Colcrys. Also, suggesting an alternative only to suggest an alternative to that alternative is idiotic. Obviously, the letter is generated by a data-crunching algorithm. But an algorithm can only be as good as the programmer creating it.
As for my other proprietary prescriptions: Lyrica was the second on my list, and Celebrex the fourth. Let me explain why this is both annoying and inefficient. Before I could prescribe those drugs, this insurer made me jump through hoops to get them. In other words, there already exists in their database proof that I had already tried their recommended alternatives.
I can only conclude that within the bowels of health insurance corporate offices, and probably in more places than I care to imagine, there are people who are either incompetent or lazy, or both, making healthcare decisions.
So, to the health insurer: Forgive me if I ignore your reminder. I already know that healthcare costs are bloated. I am already quite conscientious about my prescribing practices. I think I can speak for all rheumatologists who receive these notices: You’re barking up the wrong tree.
Dr. Chan practices rheumatology in Pawtucket, R.I.
