FROM JAMA INTERNAL MEDICINE
The U.S. military now allows transgender people to serve openly, and all medical personnel are supposed to be trained in their treatment – including care related to gender transition – by June 2017.
But a new survey of 204 family physicians who work for the military shows that most aren’t willing to prescribe cross-hormone treatment to eligible adult transgender patients.
In addition, “we found that most military clinicians did not receive any formal training on transgender care during their medical education, most had not treated a patient with gender dysphoria, and most had not received sufficient training to prescribe cross-hormone therapy,” said Natasha A. Schvey, PhD, an assistant professor with the medical and clinical psychology department at the Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences, Bethesda, Md., and lead author of a new study that summarizes the survey findings.
An estimated 12,800 transgender people serve in the U.S. military, and researchers believe that they make up a larger proportion of the military population than in the general population.
In October 2016, the Department of Defense ended its ban on service by transgender troops. A policy statement says: “Service members with a diagnosis from a military medical provider indicating that gender transition is medically necessary will be provided medical care and treatment for the diagnosed medical condition, in the same manner as other medical care and treatment.”
For the new study, Dr. Schvey and her associates surveyed 204 of the approximately 1,700 family physicians who serve the military (JAMA Intern Med. 2017 Mar 13. doi: 10.1001/jamainternmed.2017.0136). The survey respondents had all attended an annual meeting in March 2016.
Most respondents were male (62.8%) and white (85.5%); 21.7% were residents. The highest number of respondents (42.6%) worked for the U.S. Air Force.
Almost three-quarters of the respondents said that they had received no training or medical education in gender dysphoria, and 62.7% said they had never treated a transgender patient as a physician.
Just under half (47.1%) of respondents – 82 – said they would prescribe cross-hormone therapy to eligible adult patients, but only one would do so independently. The others would only do so with additional education (7.5% of all responding physicians), the help of an experienced clinician (17.2%), or both (21.8%).
The other 52.9% said they wouldn’t prescribe the hormone therapy. Eight percent of all responding physicians blamed ethical concerns, 19.5% pointed to lack of comfort, and 25.3% mentioned both, the investigators reported.
Why are so many physicians so uncomfortable?
Dr. Schvey said the survey design doesn’t allow for speculation about what the ethical concerns might be, but “the data did indicate that hours of training on transgender care were directly associated with the likelihood of prescribing cross-hormone therapy. Therefore, some of the lack of comfort may be due to lack of experience and adequate training.”
Although family physicians are generally used to treating patients with hormones for contraception and to treat perimenopausal symptoms and hypogonadism, many don’t know about dosing regimens and other information regarding their use in transgender patients, study coauthor David A. Klein, MD, assistant professor of family medicine and pediatrics at the Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences, said in an interview. And, he noted, “some are unaware that provision of cross-hormone therapy is within their scope of care.”
Going forward, “given that greater education in transgender care is associated with increased competency,” Dr. Schvey said in an interview, “it will be important to assess the training of military physicians to ensure skill and sensitivity in treating patients who identify as transgender.”
The study had no specific funding, and the authors reported no relevant conflicts of interest.
