The number of parents asking their pediatricians to stray from the recommended immunization schedule by spreading out the vaccines is increasing, and so is the number of pediatricians who are agreeing to follow these spaced-out schedules .
One of the two reasons most often given by pediatricians for agreeing to the less than optimal immunization schedules is that by showing a willingness to compromise, that physician may be helping to build a trusting relationship with these families. The other reason is a concern – let’s be honest and call it a fear – that a dissatisfied family will move its care to another physician/provider.
When we scratch the surface of these two rationales, neither seems to make much sense. The conflict over immunization spacing comes to a head at the 2-month well-child visit recommended call for six injections. If the infant has had an unremarkable neonatal course, there may not have been any situation in which the physician was forced to demonstrate her trustworthiness. As long as she has dressed professionally, showed up on time for appointments, washed her hands, and appeared genuinely interested in the child’s well-being, that’s about all she has had to do.
The physician may give the impression that she can be trusted, but real trust is usually something that must accumulate over time, in monthly – or more likely yearly – increments. Occasionally a crisis allows the physician to behave so heroically that her route to a trusting relationship is compressed to just a few hours, but fortunately these crises are rare.
Does agreeing to an unnecessary and unsubstantiated diversion from the recommended immunization schedule play a role in trust building? It may signal that the physician is willing to compromise, which in some situations may not be a bad attribute. For example, the mother who has struggled and failed at breastfeeding her 6 weeks despite everyone’s best efforts will appreciate her pediatrician’s willingness to compromise. But should compromise of scientifically validated practices really be one of the cornerstones of a physician-patient relationship?
I have never had a family request that the immunization schedule be spread out for their second child because they have seen for themselves that the process is not what they have feared. I gave all the immunizations myself, and my administration style was quick and matter-of-fact. The problem, of course, is getting hesitant parents up to and over that hurdle of the 2-month visit. Unfortunately, the evidence seems to be that education and extra time and reassurance are of little value in getting them to that point of trust.
The more difficult issue is a physician’s fear that by failing to agree to a spaced-out schedule, she will open a spigot and families will flow out of her practice to other more compromising providers. Is this just an ego thing? No one likes to feel rejected. Will the feared patient exodus seriously depress the physician’s income or will it be merely a trickle that can be ignored? Obviously, the answer varies from community to community. Do families have so many options that they will easily be able to find a provider who is eager to grow his or her practice, and is less concerned about the immunization level of the community? Or, is the pediatrician so busy that a firm adherence to the standard schedule might provide a welcome opportunity to have a more manageable panel size, and at the same time shift the patient mix toward families that don’t require the extra time in fruitless “educational” discussions?
These are questions that don’t seem to be getting asked. What are the numbers? Is the loss of patients just an irrational fear for physicians created by an irrational fear of a small segment of the population? If the physician practices in a group, could her fear of patient loss be eased if the entire group committed itself to following the standard immunization schedule? Are group members discussing this issue among themselves and with their practice managers? Or, is everyone just spacing out?
Dr. Wilkoff practiced primary care pediatrics in Brunswick, Maine, for nearly 40 years. He has authored several books on behavioral pediatrics, including “Coping with a Picky Eater.” E-mail him at pdnews@frontlinemedcom.com. Scan this QR code to read similar articles or go to pediatricnews.com.
