FROM JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY
High-deductible health insurance plans may be bad for women’s health, suggest results of a new study.
An analysis of data on women without evidence of breast cancer who were covered for at least 1 year in a low annual deductible plan and then switched by their employers to high annual deductible plans showed that when women were forced to shell out substantially more money before their insurance kicked in, they were significantly more likely to have delays in diagnostic breast imaging, breast biopsy, and initiation of chemotherapy.
“Such delays might lead to adverse long-term breast cancer outcomes. Policymakers, health insurers, and employers should consider designing or incentivizing health insurance benefits that facilitate transitions through key steps along the cancer care pathway,” wrote J. Frank Wharam, MB, and colleagues at Harvard Medical School and Harvard Pilgrim Health Care Institute in Boston. The report was published in Journal of Clinical Oncology .
The investigators conducted a controlled pre-post study to measure the occurrence of outcomes both before and after women were switched from a low-deductible health plan, defined as a maximum annual deductible of $500 or less, to a high-deductible plan, defined as an annual deductible of $1,000 or more.
The study population comprised 273,499 women aged 25-64 years who had no evidence of breast cancer before they were included in the study. The women had all been enrolled in a low-deductible plan for at least 1 year, and were then switched by employer mandate to a high-deductible plan and followed for up to 4 additional years.
Controls included 2.4 million women matched by time of inclusion whose employers continued to offer only low-deductible health plans.
Although at baseline there were no differences between the study sample and the controls in time to first diagnostic breast imaging, breast biopsy, diagnosis of early stage breast cancer, or initiation of breast cancer chemotherapy, at follow-up the women who had been switched to the high-deductible plans had significant delays in all categories.
Compared with controls, the hazard ratios (HR) for each parameter were as follows:
Time to first diagnostic breast imaging: HR = 0.96 (95% confidence interval 0.94-0.96)
Time to first breast biopsy: HR = 0.92 (0.89-0.95)
Time to early stage breast cancer diagnosis: HR = 0.83 (0.78-0.90)
Time to breast cancer chemotherapy: HR = 0.79 (0.72-0.86)
“The findings imply that the high out-of-pocket obligations under HDHPs [high-deductible health plans] might be a barrier to timely receipt of essential breast cancer services. Women in HDHPs might either delay presenting for concerning symptoms or, if proceeding along the pathway from breast cancer screening to diagnostic testing to treatment, be hesitant to undergo subsequent (and generally more expensive) care,” the authors wrote.
They noted that initially modest delays in diagnostic imaging appeared to snowball into longer delays as women proceeded through stages of care.
They recommend a strategy whereby insurers carve out exemptions to high deductibles for services such as diagnostic imaging and breast biopsy.
SOURCE: Wharam et al. J Clin Oncol. 2018 Feb 28. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2017.75.2501 .